The following students from the Class of 2009 received Alumni Scholarships.
| Student | Parent(s) | College |
|---|---|---|
| Taelor Brown | Richard & Victoria Brown | Westminster College |
| Letesia Conley | Ms. Monica L. Conley | Kent State University |
| Marissa Earl | Dennis & Stephanie Earl | Mount Union College |
| Ariel Ehmer | Jacqueline Fitch & John Taylor | Bowling Green State University |
| Elizabeth Huff | Herb & Laurie Huff | Grove City College of Pennsylvania |
| Kristina Kandel | Ronald & Pauline Kandel | Malone University |
| Kaitlin Laubert Haynam | Gordon Laubert & Lorie Callahan | Malone University |
| Erin Leffler | Kimberly & David Leffler, Jr. | Capital University |
| Hannah Leffler | Richard & Barbara Leffler | Westminster College/The Ohio State University |
| Lin Ling | Mr. & Mrs. Lam Wo | New York University |
| Jennifer McFadden Gordon B. Williams Scholarship |
Michael & Elizabeth McFadden | Malone University |
| Amanda Norris | John & Michelle Norris | Hiram College |
| Jenna Peters | Donald & Lorraine Peters | University of Cincinnati |
| Douglas Remley | Sean & Tiffany Remley | The George Washington University |
| Sara Robinson | David & Jill Robinson | Walsh University |
| Ariana Sampsel | Bruce & Brenda Sampsel | Bowling Green State University |
| John Tyler Smith | Chris & Debbi Smith | Western State College of Colorado |
| Sara Winkler | Mark & Alms Winkler | Otterbein College/Grove City College |
| Olivia Fulton | Donald & Christine Fulton | Ohio University |